A community in Shanghai is replacing new fire doors for free. Why are residents even more worried?

Recently

Qingpu District Yuxiu Xinyuan Community

Residents have been

replacing fire doors in the community

Expressed dissatisfaction and doubts

↓↓↓

In December last year, the property management company changed the property in the community without fully informing the residents of the relevant information. Partial fire doors. These newly installed fire doors do not have any brand, model or other identification, nor do they have permanent nameplates that comply with national standards. This has triggered residents\’ concerns about the quality and safety of these fire door products.

Let’s take a look with Fangji

In October last year, the fire doors on the first floor of Building 20 and Building 21 in the community were replaced due to damage. . On December 10, the property management posted another warm reminder, announcing that it would replace all fire doors in the entire community with steel ones, and the cost would be subsidized by the government.

Residents have repeatedly asked the property management company to provide basic information on new fire doors, but they have never received a clear answer. While residents were still waiting for news, at the end of December last year, the property management company suddenly The fire doors leading to the non-motor vehicle garages on the first floor of the other 21 buildings in the community have been replaced. However, the newly installed fire doors do not have any brand, model or other signs, and the style is also the same as the two fire doors that were replaced in October. The door is completely different.

Residents of Yuxiu Xinyuan Community:

After it was installed, we did not see any test reports or certificates of conformity, including relevant fire protection nameplates.

Residents expressed deep concerns about the product quality and fire performance of the newly installed

fire doors

according to\” According to the national standard for fire doors, a permanent product logo nameplate must be fixed on the fire door. The nameplate must also have product name, model, production date, batch, expiry date and other information, and should not be pasted. However, newly installed fireproof doors should not be pasted. There is no such information on the door.

Residents expressed deep concerns about the product quality and fire performance of newly installed fire doors. Everyone is worried that such fire doors will not be able to play their due role in emergencies and will bring hidden dangers to the lives and property of residents.

Residents of Yuxiu Xinyuan Community:

When we usually buy things, there is a product certificate inside, no matter which factory made it.

Residents of Yuxiu Xinyuan Community:

We cannot wait until a three-no product is installed before we pursue this issue.

Faced with residents’ doubts and concerns

The property management finally came up with a report on fire doors on the day of the reporter’s interview

>

\”Firefighting Product Certification Certificate\”

However

this certificate makes residents

More doubts and worries arose

The reporter looked through the \”Fire Protection Product Certification Certificate\” and found that the product photos displayed in the \”Certificate\” were obviously different from the fire doors installed in the community. Likewise, the fire door in the photo has insulating fireproof glass in the middle, but the one installed in the community does not.

The property introduction stated that these fire doors were purchased by the maintenance unit of the community. The person in charge of the maintenance unit explained that although the style of the fire doors they purchased did not match the photo on the certificate, The fire protection level is up to standard. They feel that as long as the fire protection level is up to standard, the style is not important. The picture is irrelevant, and the inspection report cannot be exactly the same as the door. \”

In addition, residents questioned the lack of permanent nameplates and grade information on the fire doors. The person in charge of maintenance said that the signs on the fire doors are stickers , you need to tear off the film outside the fire door and then put it back on.

Shanghai Shengxiangda Fire Engineering Co., Ltd.

Company leader Qu Xueping:

The film is still on it. After I put it on, the film came off and all the stamps were removed. (Where is it?) It can be found at the property at any time. Go get it.

Then

The person in charge of maintenance did come up with a stack of certificates and fire door signs.

But these explanations

do not eliminate everyone’s doubts

Yixiu residents District Party Branch Secretary Yang Yong:

From my personal point of view, we have verified this \”certificate\” and there should be no big problem. There are related red seals. But now I am wondering whether the door and the certificate are consistent? How can we now prove that the gate and the certificate are consistent?

In response to this point, the maintenance person in charge said that there are several products on a \”Fire Protection Product Certification Certificate\”, and he does not know himself Which batch does the door purchased belong to?

The style of the fire door does not match the \”Fire Protection Product Certification Certificate\” provided by the purchaser

This makes residents question the quality and source of the product

Serious doubts have arisen

In addition to the fire doors

the lack of necessary product representation and nameplates

Residents also expressed doubts about the purchase price of this batch of fire doors

and the source of funds

Since December last year, residents have repeatedly asked the property management department about the purchase price of these fire doors. Value, but never received a clear answer

Residents of Yuxiu Xinyuan Community:

(What is the total purchase value? (less) No one told us.

Residents of Yuxiu Xinyuan Community:

I just saw that the fire report was different from the one we pretended to have. I have reasonable doubts that he will bring it out now. The sticker on the door may indicate that the door was purchased for 500 yuan or 800 yuan, but it was affixed with a 2,000 yuan nameplate.

After asking the local management department, the reporter learned that the maintenance unit purchased 44 fire doors this time, with a total cost of more than 70,000 yuan, using government subsidies, which are rewards provided by the local Zhaoxiang Town for meeting the service standards of residential properties.

Yang Yong, Secretary of the Party Branch of Yixiu Residential Area:

Our government has seen that it (property) has been replenished, but it has not made any contribution after it was taken in. Real things, optimization There is a version in which 90% of the subsidy received by the property management company will be used to upgrade or optimize some supporting facilities in the community, of which 65% will be given priority to government guidance.

Residents of Yuxiu Xinyuan Community:

Logically, this money comes from the maintenance funds of the community. In order to solve the urgent matters of the community, and the infrastructure of this community is relatively poor, our town has made some subsidies. In order to speed up the repair of hidden dangers, Correction of the problem

Stated by the territorial management department

Since the replacement of fire doors

was led by the property management company

No maintenance funds were used

Therefore no public consultation or price comparison was conducted

Secretary of the Party Branch of Yixiu Residential Area Yang Yong:

This is implemented by the property management company. If it is implemented by the government, it must be subject to price comparison and audit by three parties. In fact, it is a subsidy and reward system rather than a real project.

Shanghai Shasha. Zhu Kai, property manager of Lin Property Management Co., Ltd.:

If we follow the normal process, the public revenue maintenance funds will definitely be used in this way, but this is a standard subsidy and may not use the owner\’s money.

In response to residents’ questions and concerns

The property manager said

Next step

will let maintenance The unit removed a fire door

and sent it to a third-party testing agency

Carry out quality inspection

Ensure the quality and safety of fire doors

The current property manager said: First of all, make sure that there is no problem with the safety of the replaced fire door, and other You can sit down and talk about the questions later. This is the right way to solve problems based on priorities. However, the questions to be solved later are actually not simple.

This fire door replacement incident is not only a dispute about the quality and procurement process of fire door products, but also a reflection on the relationship between the transparency of the use of government subsidies and the rights and interests of owners. Government subsidies were used for the purchase of fire doors. , although it is not directly funded by the owner, its use is still related to the overall interests of the community and the residential safety of the owner.

Property When deciding to use this subsidy, we should fully respect the owners\’ right to know and consult with them in an open and transparent manner to ensure that the use of the subsidy can truly meet the needs and expectations of the owners. However, in this incident, The property owner\’s lack of transparency has aroused doubts among owners and raised doubts about the use of subsidies.

The question that arises from this is whether there is a need for a supervision mechanism regarding the use of government subsidies. 90% of the government subsidies for \”standard properties\” are used for facility optimization. Are there any false projects or false prices? Is there wrong goods? If the reason is that \”it is not the owner\’s investment\”, there will be no supervision. It will not only be the owner\’s interests that will be damaged, but also the owner\’s interests. The \”standard property\” subsidy system itself

Reporter: Kang Lingkan

Source: Newsroom