Can entry door surveillance be installed? Whose rights are violated by installing an external elevator in a community? Several cases teach you the correct way to protect your rights!

People\’s livelihood is no small matter, and the branches and leaves are always related to feelings. Infringements occur from time to time in daily life and are closely related to the vital interests of the people. In order to further implement the judicial requirements of ensuring the people\’s high-quality life and promote the core socialist values, on December 12, the Changping Court held a press briefing to systematically sort out the cases involving people\’s livelihood infringement disputes that the court has heard since the implementation of the Civil Code. Report the case trial status and publish five typical cases. The press briefing was hosted by Liang Zhiyong, member of the Party Leadership Group, Director of the Political Department and Press Spokesperson of the Changping Court.

\”Partial infringement The behavior is sudden and unpredictable, which hinders the parties\’ ability to obtain and preserve evidence. \”Pan Youting, member of the Party Leadership Group and Vice President of the Changping Court, introduced that with the development of the Internet economy and the application of new technologies, the forms of infringement are no longer limited to personal and property damage, and \”Internet+\” infringement cases such as spiritual personality rights disputes are increasingly It shows the characteristics of scattered sources of communication and concealment of online behaviors. It often requires the use of technical identification and other measures to fix the facts of infringement, which brings great challenges to victims\’ rights protection. In addition, it is extremely common for infringement disputes to involve multiple litigants and multiple legal relationships. .

In practice, it has been found that some parties\’ lack of integrity, such as \”not admitting their accounts\” and \”regreting afterward\”, have intensified conflicts and caused disputes. Irregular signing of compensation agreements is also the reason for the frequent occurrence of such cases. In this regard, the Changping Court reminded the general public to strengthen Awareness of evidence retention, timely taking photos and videos and other fixed infringements to clarify the division of responsibilities. The court also called on grassroots organizations such as village (neighborhood) committees to \”combine coordination and prevention\” to achieve \”early detection and early resolution\” of conflicts and disputes. In addition, it should further increase the publicity of the rule of law to enhance the public awareness. Awareness and ability to safeguard rights

Briefing meeting Shao Min, the president of the Shahe Tribunal of Changping Court, and Zhang Yan, the deputy president of the court, released typical cases focusing on hot topics of widespread concern such as residential safety, community property management, and personal information protection.

Scan the QR code to view typical cases

Among them, a privacy dispute caused by the installation of a video doorbell attracted the attention of the media present. Zhai and his wife had a conflict with their neighbor Sun because they piled garbage and damaged the door lock. Video doorbells and surveillance cameras were installed near the windows and in the corridors. Sun believed that the video doorbells and surveillance cameras could capture his whereabouts and store and upload the footage to the Internet, infringing on his personal privacy, so he asked the two to remove them. >

Changping Court held after trial that the information of citizens entering and exiting the residence, visitor information, etc. are highly related to family and property security, private living habits, etc., and should be regarded as personal interests with a private nature and should be protected by law. Visible The doorbell and camera surveillance system can record the movements of Sun and his family. In the end, the court ruled that Zhai and Yu removed the security door to monitor the situation. Doorbell systems, indoor surveillance and corridor surveillance

In this regard, the judge reminded that while using smart devices to facilitate your own life, you must grasp the boundaries. Neighboring residents should follow the principles of legality, legitimacy and necessity when installing cameras in public corridors, and contact the police in advance as much as possible about the installation of cameras. The neighboring party should communicate well and reasonably determine the location of the camera. , height, orientation and monitoring range to avoid infringing on the private space, private activities and private information that others do not want to know. If there are disputes between neighbors about the shooting range, they can be properly resolved by adjusting the shooting angle, blocking part of the lens, etc. to build a joint community. Harmonious neighborhood relations

Before the briefing, the Changping Court held a hearing on a case of rights to life, body, and health. “The evil person complained first, and it was obvious that he beat me first. \”The original defendant is an upstairs neighbor living in a village in Shahe Town, Changping District. The two had a conflict over noise. When they met at the entrance of the village one night, they had another quarrel and got into a fight. The case will be pronounced at an optional date.

Source: Beijing-France Internet Affairs